Saturday, February 20, 2010

Reviews - An Education and The Lives of Others


I saw An Education a few weeks ago in my ongoing mission to watch all of the nominees for Best Picture at the Academy Awards this year. I did the same thing last year when there were only 5 movies to watch, and I only saw 4 of them (never caught Frost/Nixon). This year there are 10 nominees. I've seen 8. Still have Precious and A Serious Man remaining. We'll see if I end up seeing those. Anyways, I'm completely off subject on what a review should be.

An Education is about a 16 year old girl, Jenny, in Britain in the 60s at an all girls school. Jenny wants adventure and she doesn't see any point in the things they are teaching her in school. She's obsessed with the French language, art, classical music, fashion, etc. She's basically similar to what we would now call a hipster. She ends up finding this adventure in a man in his 30s, David. Like The Lives of Others below, this movie is about the transformation of a character. It's primarily a love story, but it's so much more as well. It's about being realistic, the necessity of schooling, what it means to grow older, and finding purpose in life. I really enjoyed this movie. I wouldn't rank it above some of the other Oscar nominees out there, but it's still very good. It also manages to get its story across while not moving past PG-13 content, so that goes in its favor in my book too. That definitely makes it a more accessible film anyways.


Potential based on Preview: 8/10
Actual Movie: 8.5/10



The Lives of Others takes place in East Germany in 1984. It's about the "stasi," the people that are constantly monitoring and surveying suspects that oppose the government. More specifically, it's about one member of the group, Wiesler, who has to monitor a famous writer. Wiseler is an extremely dynamic and round character, consistently being presented with situations that change him and his philosophies about his role and the government's role in the citizens lives.

This is a very very good movie. For one, it is a subject that I find incredibly interesting and thought provoking. Surveillance is still commonplace in many countries across the world, and it has had an effect on countless lives over the years. More than just having an interesting subject, The Lives of Others succeeds greatly as a film. The tension in the drama is spot on. The characters are all believable, from being realistically despicable to lovable. And the ending... I won't give anything away, but the ending is awesome. The ending made the slightly slower middle portion of the movie totally worth it. I was dissapointed in 2007 when Pan's Labyrinth lost the Best Foreign Language Film to The Lives of Others. I still think I prefer Pan's Labyrinth, but I can completely see why this movie ended up taking the Oscar.

So who is this movie for? It is subtitled so that might turn some people off. Also, you can imagine the kind of content a movie has when it is based around being able to have video and audio surveillance in someone's house. It deservedly gets an R rating. That may also come from its European creators. Knowing those things, decide for yourself if it's for you or not.


Potential based on Preview: 9/10
Actual Movie: 9/10

No comments: