Saturday, January 30, 2010

Review - Lady in the Water


Lady in the Water was M. Night Shyamalan's last movie before he gave up on making good films entirely. For now. The Last Airbender actually could be pretty cool... maybe. Hopefully. Anyways, back to Lady in the Water.

Lady in the Water is a film that desperately wants to be good, and has a lot of things going for it, but I never felt like it went "all-in" with what it was trying to accomplish. Instead, it just skirts the edges of what it would be like if a fairytale was real.

The biggest thing I disliked about Lady in the Water is that it never successfully brought me into the world. At no point in time did I believe these were real people. All of the characters felt like stereotypes and exaggerations. I didn't didn't buy them in the least, except for the main character Cleveland. It was as if Shyamalan thought the audience wouldn't be able to handle the weirdness of a fairyale coming to life in a real world, so he had to create this off-kilter world, and that ultimately just put me off.

On the same note, I really didn't like the comedy in the movie. That's not to say it wasn't funny. It was funny. But that's the problem. Lady in the Water has a somewhat serious story, and all of the comedy feels very forced. It's as if I'm in a serious situation and one of the people around me can't handle being serious, so they make a joke, ruining any semblance of seriousness and taking me out of the situation. There are 3 main examples I can think of here in which the comedy was funny, but took me out of the movie: Any time the Asian college student was around, any time Reggie was around (big arm dude), and the scene in which the movie critic has something... well, unfortunate happen to him. The only comedy that actually kept me in the world was the lady who would tell us everything about her husband. Everything. It was realistic. It was humorous. It wasn't forced. On top of that, it fit very nicely into how things wrapped up at the end.

Okay, now onto the things I liked. The score for the movie is amazing. Shyamalan definitely knows how to grab good composers and get them to fit into his movie perfectly. Not only that, but the score successfully amplifies so many scenes that would have only been lame to mediocre otherwise. Also, the story is really good. I love when fantasy and reality intertwine. For some people, that's off-putting and they can't wrap their minds around it enough to enjoy those stories, but for me, I love it. Paul Giamatti does an amazing job in the lead role of Cleveland, and I really wish he would get more lead roles. Finally, the cinematography is fantastic. I absolutely loved some of the shots that Shyamalan pulled off. The perspective, the angles, the lighting... it all worked so well. I especially loved the shots from underwater looking up into our world. They were creative and powerful. The last scene would have had a completely different feel if it was shot outside of the water and you actually saw what was happening. Having the camera in the water gave it a strong sense of reality and emotion, and probably saved some CGI money as well.

All in all, Lady in the Water is an "ok" movie. It's not bad (though if you can't get past the seemingly unreal story you probably won't like it at all), but it's not really good either. It's full of good and great things, but Shymalan's biggest mistake in this movie is in not making the world real enough to actually believe. That's a shame, because the movie completely grounds itself in the fact that you will believe in what is happening on screen. Shyamalan panders to a wider audience through the use of comic relief and unbelievable characters. If not for that, I could have really loved this movie, but because of that, I can't. Believing in a world and being a part of a world for 2 hours is why I watch movies, and I didn't believe in Lady in the Water.

What this movie wanted desperately to do, Pan's Labyrinth did. If you want an amazing movie where a fairytale world and the real world come together, and you don't mind subtitles, watch Pan's Labyrinth.

Potential based on Preview: 8/10
Actual Movie: 6.5/10

Friday, January 29, 2010

Reviews - Big Fan/Imaginarium/Smoking

Big Fan stars Patton Oswalt as an obsessed fan of the New York Giants. The movie follows his fanatacism with the team and the star quarterback, and his dealings with an Eagles fan that borderline torments him. It's a very unique movie with a story that keeps you going through the whole thing, and even has a few surprises. Big Fan is written by the same guy that wrote The Wrestler, so that should give you some idea of what kind of a movie it is. Also, it's definitely a straight up indie drama, so don't expect anything mainstream here... not that you would expect that from me anyways. For what it is, it's a good movie, and the only reason I didn't rate it any higher is because I personally wasn't as grabbed by it as I have been other movies. The topic was an interesting view into the world of a crazy football fan, which I definitely can't relate to, but is intriguing nonetheless.

Potential based on Preview: 8/10
Actual Movie: 7.5/10

This movie is crazy. Absolutely nuts. Also, it is Heath Ledger's last movie, which if you're a big fan of his this should be reason enough to see it. He died during the filming of this one. After watching it, maybe you'll see why. It's a visual druggy trip. The story is decent, although it isn't anything too special and I really wasn't too wrapped into it. The acting is good, as is the set design and costume work. Most of the points I gave for this one is for the visuals alone... it's gorgeous, strange, artistic... imagine going into the imagination of the guy that made all of the Monty Python stuff, and this is what you would get. Because that's who made this movie - except for the fact that it's nothing like Monty Python.

Potential based on Preview: 9/10
Actual Movie: 6/10

Thank You for Smoking (2005) comes from Jason Reitman, the guy who brought us Juno and my almost-1st-place movie of last year, Up in the Air. It was his first major release, and since getting Netflix (hence all of these reviews), I decided it was time to check it out. I'm glad I did. It's a really good movie, highly comedic, and it makes a lot of good points about our society as well, from multiple sides of the issue.

The movie is about a lawyer for the tobacco industry whose purpose is to make the industry look good, guard them from unwanted lawsuits, and make cigarettes look acceptable in the public eye. He's a definite anti-hero who you want to dislike, but for some reason you just can't. One of the most interesting things I noticed in the movie is that I didn't see anyone smoking once. Not once. I'm sure this was highly intentional (and somewhat self referential - which you'll understand after watching it). The movie is definitely not pro-smoking; however I wouldn't call it an hour and a half long anti-smoking ad either. It just tells it like it is, in hilariously clever ways.

Potential based on Preview: 9/10
Actual Movie: 8.5/10

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Would You Be Interested?

Okay, so I've been tossing around an idea with some people the past month or two, and I think I've decided to go ahead and make it happen.

We all know I'm a pretty big movie nerd. No secret. Also, we all also know how anal I can be about watching movies in groups, so much so that I avoid doing it a lot of times. However, this creates a problem. There are a lot of good movies out there that people haven't seen that I want to share with people, but I don't want to just mass-invite everyone. That will create a situation of people talking, chomping on chips, and not enjoying the movie because it's "weird" or whatever. I also don't want to selectively invite people to things just because, well, I don't like doing that.

Therefore, I've decided I'd like to start a group for people that appreciate weird/unique/indie/obscure movies. We can meet maybe once a week or once every two weeks or whatever it ends up being, and we'll hang out some, do whatever, watch the movie, talk about it, something like that. But basically, it's a group for people that would prefer to watch a movie than have a conversation during it. It's also a group for people who like more obscure things, meaning we won't ever be watching The Proposal or Braveheart or The Dark Knight. Instead, expect more things like Memento, (500) Days of Summer, Garden State, Primer, and City of God.

The Rules/Facts:
- No conversations during the movie, or blatantly making fun of stuff during it.
- No loud food items.
- Movies with cursing, nudity, etc, will NOT be avoided and scenes will not be skipped. The kind of stuff we'll be watching won't throw that stuff in just for the sake of making it an R-rated flick like a lot of trashy comedies these days. You can close your eyes and plug your ears if you want.
- The movie being watched each time will be announced ahead of time, so no scrambling for "what are we going to watch tonight."
- I may start us off, but we can basically vote/decide movies, won't just be me.
- This isn't the kind of thing where you have to show up for every movie either, it's a pick-and-choose sort of event. Some weeks it may just be me, other weeks it may be 10 of us.
- It will in fact be a social event, but it won't be social DURING the movie.
- If you have to pee during the movie, we'll pause it, we're not that anal and cruel.
- The point of everything is to experience a film you may have never seen or really love and want to see again.

I'm considering making the first one on January 30th (that's a Saturday). Not set on anything though. Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday evenings work best for me.

Okay, so, now's the time where I actually NEED comments. Who is interested? When would work good for you? Do you have any other ideas or thoughts?

Monday, January 18, 2010

Reviews - 5 Different Movies

Wasn't expecting much from this movie, but I got slightly more than I expected. It's fun, though predictable. I suppose I just dislike the action side of Sherlock Holmes and I wish it had been more detective/mystery. They did a really good job with the action, and it was enjoyable, but that wasn't the side of the story I wanted to see.

Also, though Robert Downey Jr. was amazing, I never once saw him as Sherlock Holmes. I just kept seeing him as Downey (how the HECK did he win the Golden Globe?). That kept my mind of out of the experience, and being engaged in a film is a really big thing for me. It's an okay flick though. I'd watch it again if someone was doing a house party or something with it on, but that's about it. Fun in the moment, but very forgettable over time.

Potential based on Preview: 6/10
Actual Movie: 6.5/10


This movie had one of my favorite previews of 2009, thus I was highly looking forward to it. Then the reviews came, and I decided to not even bother - until it came to the $1 theater. In retrospect, I should have seen it when it came out, because the $1 theater was awful and I could barely hear half the characters' lines. So the score could be one point higher if I actually understood stuff.

The movie is extremely well made and I absolutely loved the art style it took. It was a faithful adaptation to a book with no story to begin with. I loved how the movie treated being a child. It wasn't a romanticized view and it wasn't an overly dark view; it was real. I could at least relate to it anyways. It is pretty odd though and I have a feeling most general audiences would come out of it with a huge question mark on their faces. Also, it's not a kids' movie. It should never have been marketed like that. This is a movie about childhood for adults.

Potential based on Preview: 10/10
Actual Movie: 7/10

Thirst is the vampire love story movie that all Twilight fans should see. It will completely destroy their lives and they will yell at me if they actually do end up seeing it, but whatever. It portrays the classical vampire in the most realistic way I have ever seen. What would it really be like? How would you eat? How would a relationship actually work with someone who isn't a vampire? What kind of crazy stuff would you actually have to bring yourself down to do? The movie addresses all of these questions in an extremely disturbing manner. This movie is not for the easily faint. Example: There's one scene where the vampire (who doesn't want to kill humans) literally unplugs the end of an IV attached to the machine from a guy in a coma, and proceeds to suck the blood out of the guy. Disturbing.

The story is good though. The images stay with you and there are some really artistic shots. However, I felt like the movie dragged on and I really wasn't in to it until over halfway through. It's a foreign film so I can't really comment on the acting, but it annoyed me how the subtitles consistently said "cuz" instead of "because" or "cause." Weird. Finally, I didn't see the preview before seeing the movie, so that section is blank.

Potential based on Preview: ?/10
Actual Movie: 7.5/10

Once is a indie musical set in Ireland. I use the term "musical" very very loosely. The movie is entirely based on a guy and girl's musical talents and how they work together and how music brings them together. Thus, 70% of the movie is them singing songs or playing guitar or recording tracks.

There's a lot to like about this movie. I loved the story, the acting was great, the script was very original, the actual music was my kind of thing (acoustic and piano stuff), and I genuinely felt for the characters. It's one of those kind of movies that doesn't take you down a road you've ever seen before on the big screen. It ask questions. It feels more like real life - the ending especially. And that's not to say it's a sad movie. Parts of it are kind of sad, but I wouldn't say it is a sad movie at all. It really just breaks all the formula rules and makes you think. Great movie.

Potential based on Preview: ?/10
Actual Movie: 9/10

The first thing I noticed in this movie that I loved was character interaction. The couple has such a unique way of interacting. Some would say it has clever dialogue, and they may not be wrong, but it's more clever interaction. It feels as if the couple in the movie really is in love and have their own way of expressing it that they have created over years and years of knowing each other. It's really entertaining and touching.

The story is pretty simple, but that isn't bad. This movie isn't about story. It's about characters, life, growing older, and whether you are making the right decisions or not. Is this really where we should be in life right now? Isn't there something more? Did we mess up somewhere? It's a couples' journey answering these questions by going across the country and visiting friends to find a new city to move to. It's hilarious, moving, cute, and very entertaining. It's definitely an R-rated film though, so yeah, if you're offended by that sort of stuff...

Potential based on Preview: 8/10
Actual Movie: 8.5/10