Sunday, February 12, 2012

The Hunger Games [Book Review]


After well over a year of hearing about The Hunger Games trilogy in podcasts, from friends, from random people, etc, I finally gave it a shot. Admittedly, I was a little bit wary because of it's categorization as "young adult" fiction. However, with the movie coming out soon and everything, I decided I couldn't delay much longer. Thus, I broke down and read it.

Not gonna say a whole lot on it really except to say that the hype holds up. It's genuinely a very entertaining good read, and it goes places I really didn't expect it to go at all (especially in relation to the games). From the very first chapter or two my predictions started completely falling flat. The games themselves were enormously entertaining to read through, and took up a much larger portion of the book than I anticipated.

The only thing I really didn't like (and it is a huge thing) was the main character. Katniss. She was okay at the beginning, and I definitely understand her motivations and thought processes... but I was constantly annoyed with her, especially once the games started. She was so so clueless about how she was affecting other people for almost the whole book. That wasn't fun to read. It was annoying. It made me angry at her character. From the moment Gale entered the scene, I understood his perspective and where he was coming from. From the moment Peeta entered the scene, I understood his perspective and where he was coming from. I feel like at some point or another I've been in both of their positions. Katniss though? She had no freaking clue about anything. Everything with her felt extremely selfishly motivated and uncaring towards others' emotions. I couldn't handle it.

At this point, I'm debating whether I even want to read the 2nd book. All the end of the 1st book did was set up team Edward/Jacob situation that I don't care about at all. If there's a genuinely exciting plot with cool stuff going on, I'll read it, but I definitely don't feel like it's going there at this point.

It's strange. I'd still recommend the book to most people, and I genuinely did really really like it... so it's odd that I'm saying so much negative stuff. Maybe it's just a male thing. Maybe females really understand the conflicts that Katniss deals with. I think she deals with those conflicts in the poorest ways possible. She never cares about anyones' emotions except for her own and what the audience might be feeling. It's painful to even read.

What do y'all think? Am I just coming at things from the male perspective? Should I still move on to book 2, or is it exactly what I fear it will be?

The Hunger Games: 8/10

4 comments:

marybeth said...

ive heard of this series and know the movie's coming out, but you have me intrigued now, especially to compare the male/female perspective. i'll give it a read and get back to you. i know you'll be on the edge of your seat waiting to hear!.....

Stacie said...

I must say I love this series, so I recommend that you read book 2. Yes there is a bit of a love triangle started, but don't write it off quite yet. I admit that it probably is more geared to female readers, but it is much more guy-friendly than Twilight. The other 2 books will surprise you like the first one... it definitely keeps you on the edge of your seat. I will say that Katniss becomes less selfish in book 2 (sort of...)

Mister Woodles said...

My worry is that a great many of the people who promote the Hunger Games are some of the same ones who promoted Twilight before the backlash kicked in.

I imagine that a large part of its appeal is the ease of access in the style that young adult novels are written in (much like Harry Potter). I will eventually give it a shot, but I can't guarantee I'll be as enthusiastic about it as many others are.

Unknown said...

Yeah, I didn't read it because of that originally. But I heard enough people, mix of guys and girls, from a mix of backgrounds and other trusted sources, that I gave it a shot. It is an easy to read teen novel, no doubt about it, but it's a good one.

I hope it gets the same publicity/following as Twilight. This deserves it infinitely more than those books.

... I kind of take that back a little though. I don't want the following to be as obnoxious and weird as Twilight :)