Saturday, January 30, 2010

Review - Lady in the Water


Lady in the Water was M. Night Shyamalan's last movie before he gave up on making good films entirely. For now. The Last Airbender actually could be pretty cool... maybe. Hopefully. Anyways, back to Lady in the Water.

Lady in the Water is a film that desperately wants to be good, and has a lot of things going for it, but I never felt like it went "all-in" with what it was trying to accomplish. Instead, it just skirts the edges of what it would be like if a fairytale was real.

The biggest thing I disliked about Lady in the Water is that it never successfully brought me into the world. At no point in time did I believe these were real people. All of the characters felt like stereotypes and exaggerations. I didn't didn't buy them in the least, except for the main character Cleveland. It was as if Shyamalan thought the audience wouldn't be able to handle the weirdness of a fairyale coming to life in a real world, so he had to create this off-kilter world, and that ultimately just put me off.

On the same note, I really didn't like the comedy in the movie. That's not to say it wasn't funny. It was funny. But that's the problem. Lady in the Water has a somewhat serious story, and all of the comedy feels very forced. It's as if I'm in a serious situation and one of the people around me can't handle being serious, so they make a joke, ruining any semblance of seriousness and taking me out of the situation. There are 3 main examples I can think of here in which the comedy was funny, but took me out of the movie: Any time the Asian college student was around, any time Reggie was around (big arm dude), and the scene in which the movie critic has something... well, unfortunate happen to him. The only comedy that actually kept me in the world was the lady who would tell us everything about her husband. Everything. It was realistic. It was humorous. It wasn't forced. On top of that, it fit very nicely into how things wrapped up at the end.

Okay, now onto the things I liked. The score for the movie is amazing. Shyamalan definitely knows how to grab good composers and get them to fit into his movie perfectly. Not only that, but the score successfully amplifies so many scenes that would have only been lame to mediocre otherwise. Also, the story is really good. I love when fantasy and reality intertwine. For some people, that's off-putting and they can't wrap their minds around it enough to enjoy those stories, but for me, I love it. Paul Giamatti does an amazing job in the lead role of Cleveland, and I really wish he would get more lead roles. Finally, the cinematography is fantastic. I absolutely loved some of the shots that Shyamalan pulled off. The perspective, the angles, the lighting... it all worked so well. I especially loved the shots from underwater looking up into our world. They were creative and powerful. The last scene would have had a completely different feel if it was shot outside of the water and you actually saw what was happening. Having the camera in the water gave it a strong sense of reality and emotion, and probably saved some CGI money as well.

All in all, Lady in the Water is an "ok" movie. It's not bad (though if you can't get past the seemingly unreal story you probably won't like it at all), but it's not really good either. It's full of good and great things, but Shymalan's biggest mistake in this movie is in not making the world real enough to actually believe. That's a shame, because the movie completely grounds itself in the fact that you will believe in what is happening on screen. Shyamalan panders to a wider audience through the use of comic relief and unbelievable characters. If not for that, I could have really loved this movie, but because of that, I can't. Believing in a world and being a part of a world for 2 hours is why I watch movies, and I didn't believe in Lady in the Water.

What this movie wanted desperately to do, Pan's Labyrinth did. If you want an amazing movie where a fairytale world and the real world come together, and you don't mind subtitles, watch Pan's Labyrinth.

Potential based on Preview: 8/10
Actual Movie: 6.5/10

No comments: